Silva or Calafiori?

On projected points alone, Silva is ahead by 1.7 over the next six gameweeks. That is not the whole answer.

Silva

Bournemouth · DEF · £5.0m

Projected, next 6 GW
21.4
Chance of starting
94%
Owned by
0.8%
Points this season
29
Minutes
720

Calafiori

Arsenal · DEF · £6.0m

Hip injury - 75% chance of playing

Projected, next 6 GW
19.7
Chance of starting
63%
Owned by
52.5%
Points this season
45
Minutes
609

The answer nobody else gives you

Silva is owned by 0.8% of managers, against 52.5% for Calafiori.

If you are chasing someone in your mini-league, the less-owned player is usually the right pick even when he projects slightly lower — points from a player your rival also owns cancel out and cannot close the gap. If you are defending a lead, take the one your rival already has: matching them removes their chance to gain on you.

Global ownership is only a proxy. What actually matters is whether the specific people in your league own him.

Check who owns them in my league

Projected by gameweek

Projected points for Silva and Calafiori by gameweek
GWSilvaCalafioriDifference
93.53.0+0.6
103.63.8−0.2
113.53.3+0.3
123.43.2+0.2
133.53.3+0.3
143.83.3+0.5

Projections are ours, not FPL's. Measured error 1.19 points per player per gameweek over the last 5. How we calculate them

Silva or Calafiori? FPL comparison · Overtake